h2o

Newest.

 

Oversharpened, flare is distracting, effects are quite nice, but no depth/real composition makes my eyes jitter like bitches.

 

Thanks for the CC, just not the makes my eyes jitter like bitches xD

Unfortunately the stock was low quality, but I still wanted to use it.. so the outcome is a bit weird like you say

 

I've seen this stock. Not much at all has been done to it at all mate :\

 

I think i've done enough.
Simplicity can be nice too, I think a lot of effects would ruin this.

 

All I see done is a gradient/curves and a light source.

I agree on the simplicity can be nice, But if you're going to post something for CnC It should have more effects,etc.

 

Light source is too strong. I agree with the others, I think you could have done more with this, and still kept it simple.

 

Theres not much to it, but what you did change from the stock made it worse :S

 

I agree, the light source is too strong. Makes the bubbles to bright

 

Over sharpened, light is to bright, and I don't like the glare.

 

I don't agree. Creating something on photoshop isn't all about how much layers and effects you get down.

For OP the tag looks nice, but I can't really make out what's in it. Well I saw the original stock so I get the picture now but maybe you should try to make it more cleat. Oversharpened like said before ^

 

Agreed I've seen beautiful 4 layer signatures, making a signature doesn't have to be complex and if you think that then you should look a little more into graphics ;P. Anyways, this signature has its flaws and I listed above what I think they are, which is about all you've done with this stock.

 

This is true, but like I stated above there is no need to post something with minimal work done for critique as there is nothing to critique on.

 

Agreed, but if you post up your work on GFX ShowCase people will Critique it anyways. I honestly think it is a good sig from what you have done. I just think you overdid the little effects you have. If the lighting was a bit lower and not sharpened as much, I think this signature would look nice even if simple.

 

Thanks for the comment Saito, I know I would get CnC like this though.. but it's always good!

 

Pretty nice